ARGville

A Community for anyone living in a reality-based world -- Visit us daily to:
-- express opinions about current events, politics, religion, and society
-- share advice about relationships, dating, and parenting
-- rant about your life, work, friends, and partners
-- relax with humor and short stories

To celebrate the joys of motherhood (and fatherhood) and to help overcome its challenges.
New mother shares her experiences, posts useful articles, and answers questions about pregnancy, childbirth, childcare, and maternity.


 


Our discussion forum is open for business. Come say hello. 

Friday, March 10, 2006

 

Stay at Home Mom vs. Working Mom

Good Morning America has reen running a series, "The Mommy Wars." Full article here. One of their guests was Linda Hirschman, a law professor/working mom who wrote an article about working mothers in 2005 for American Prospect Magazine. She states that "an alarming number of college-educated women are leaving the work force to stay at home and raise their children, a trend that is a tragedy not only for mothers, but ultimately their children and women as a whole."

She goes on to say choosing to stay home is bad for women. "A good life for humans includes the classical standard of using one's capacities for speech and reason in a prudent way, the liberal requirement of having enough autonomy to direct one's own life, and the utilitarian test of doing more good than harm in the world," Hirshman wrote. "Measured against these time-tested standards, the expensively educated, upper-class moms will be leading lesser lives."

"Statistically there is no difference in the happiness levels of the children whose mothers work and the children whose mothers stay at home," she says.

What on earth?! I don't need statistics to tell me that my child WILL benefit from being raised by her parent, be it mother or father. I don't need statistics to tell me that staying at home to raise my child WILL make my child happy, content and secure.

And who is this woman to say that "a good life for humans includes the classical standard of using one's capacities for speech and reason in a prudent way." Look, lady. Maybe MY idea of a good life is staying home and playing patty-cake with my daughter, taking her to the playground and going to mommy-and-me classes. And so do I lose my capacity for speech and reason by not having intellectual conversations? Since it's not used in a prudent way is it meaningless? A lesser life? You got some nerve, woman.

Raising a child is THE toughest job a woman, or man, can do. It is an awesome responsibility that does not end at 5 pm. It is a 24/7 job, with overtime and on-call duties. To actually be the person responsible for molding and directing a totally impressionable mind--it can be an overwhelming task. Creating my child to be a morally-conscious, disciplined, joyous human IS a job that DOES NOT have detrimental consequences for myself or my daughter if I'm a working mom or a stay-at home mom.

Right now, my husband is staying home with our daughter but soon we will be switching. Daddies leaving the workforce is a trend happening across America and it made sense for our family. We made the priority of one of us to be home with her at all times. We wanted the same faith and morals that WE had to be passed on to her. We did not want to drop her off at day care or rely on a babysitter to instill these values. But my beliefs still are the same, even if I am not the parent staying home.

I hate to go to work. I just adore that little girl and every morning I say good-bye to her my heart just melts. But it makes me feel good knowing that my husband, her daddy, will be with her all day. It's what works for us, and that's what counts. If you're a woman who just couldn't stand to be home all day--WORK! If you can't stand to be away from your kids--STAY HOME! And don't feel guilty about the choices you make. Decide to do what's best for your family and your child. Don't let studies and "experts" dictate how you run your lives and raise your child.

Any opinions???


Comments:
Somehow I wish the message was: it's fine to be an at-work mom and it's fine to be an at-home mom. This author has an annoying in-your-face attitude.

When a parent wants to stay home but can't afford it, or is at-home only because they can't find a job, that's bad. But if it's by choice, whatever they do is fine.
 
I agree, if you CHOOSE to stay at home, educated or not, it's YOUR decision. Who does this lady think she is?
 
Stacy a got your back 100%. I am going to be the father of twin girls and could not imagine having to drop my girls to strangers every morning. My wife will be a stay at home mom and this will be the only way that we would have it. My wife is feeling some what guilty about not contributing financially to the family. I had her read your article and it provided her with motivation better. There is no price tag that you can put on a mom taking care of her family.
Thank You
Very Respectfully,
Chuck
 
Contributing financially is not the only contribution one can make to the family. Raising a child is THE toughest job any one person can do. And it is THE most rewarding. You'll soon see that the "sacrifices" you think you're making for your kids, aren't even sacrfices. It's what comes naturally.

We struggled at first with the role-reversal and dealing with societal sterotypes--but when it comes down to do it, we want the best for our daughter. Raising a joyful, content, secure, independent, loving, respectful child is the top priority in our life. Not to get the biggest paycheck, drive the fanciest car and wear the most in-style clothes. Your wife will be so glad when she looks back and knows that she did what was best for her, and your girls. I wish you both the best!
 
Post a Comment



<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

 


Contact Us | Resource Links